Comey’s Testimony

Let me try to put into a few hundred words the bottom-line meaning of James Comey’s testimony before the Senate Intelligence Committee:

  1. The president of the US is a liar and cannot be trusted to speak the truth.
  2. The president is willing to sabotage the proper functioning of democratic governance—especially checks on executive power—in order to ensure that his will be done.
  3. Presidential obstruction of justice and abuse of power now rise to the top of investigative and political concern. Trump clearly directed Comey to drop the investigation of Flynn, made loyalty to him the condition of Comey’s continuation in office, and confirmed that Comey’s persistence in investigating the Trump-Russia connection was the ultimate reason for firing Comey.
  4. The president felt no urgency about or interest in the Russian threat to the US electoral system.
  5. Republicans will go to great lengths to undermine and trivialize Comey’s testimony. Their mission, as they see it, is to preserve the Trump presidency long enough, at least, to push through their major domestic legislation—health care and tax changes.
  6. No objective person can come away from this hearing believing that Comey, speaking under oath and with a long record of integrity in government service, is lying while the President, not under oath and with an even longer record of deceit, is telling the truth.


  1. Sounds pretty spot on. But I do wonder whether, with all the disarray in the White House and the distrust of Trump among a number of Republicans in White House, they might have more interest in pushing Trump out of office, so that Mike Pence can take the helm. They have much more ideological alignment with Pence, and could get much more of their agenda accomplished without all these other distractions. If so, those of us who oppose Trump, might want to see him bumble along in office for a few more years.

  2. Keep Trump in office. He is wounded and will have a hard time passing the Republican agenda , Heath destruction and tax breaks for the wealthy, through congress
    Pence knows how to work congress and will get legislation passed quickly

  3. Mel, I agree with all of your points. Right on.

    One qualification, but certainly no excuse for Mr. Trump: I don’t think he understands his legal-constitutional limits and obligations. I think he is ignorant, doesn’t know any better, and may not listen to any advisers who do, if he has any.

  4. Excellent, as always, Mel…thank you. How the hell some people can’t see the duplicitous nature of Trump simply astounds me.

  5. Mel:

    Good summary of the Comey testimony.

    But a question on #5, where you state that Republicans seek to preserve the Trump presidency so as to push

    through their major domestic agenda: Would they have better success in doing so under President Pence?

    Conversely, aren’t the myriad Trump distractions impeding progress on the GOP agenda? If so, why don’t

    Republicans see this, and throw Trump under the bus? Or are they waiting for a better moment—more

    smoking guns—to do so? My wife is totally convinced that Pence would be worse for America, and that

    we should hope that Trump stays in office so that the GOP continues to make itself look utterly foolish to the

    benefit of a Democrat landslide. Or, if Pence is sucked under by association with Trump, a President Ryan would

    be still better for the GOP agenda, but worse for America and the human interest.

    Progress on “The Trexit Scenarios,” promised on several occasions, has been stalled because I just returned from a nine-day vacation in the Azores. I’m now ready to resume, and the question of Pence being better for the GOP is a major consideration. Would he have been

    stupid enough to exit the Paris climate agreement?

    * Mke

  6. I tend to agree with the view that a Pence or a Ryan would be worse for real policy matters than a Trump continuing to spin around in ever-crazier circles. Yet, everyone could be worse off if Trump manages to hang on for the rest of his term. Who knows what he might do in a desperate state of mind? It’s a tough call, and it’s for the Republicans to make, though it might not be if they lose control of Congress in the 2018 election.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s