I ended a recent post by asking when someone would step forward to bring about a cease-fire. Well, John Kerry eventually answered the call. But by the time he left Tel Aviv and a 12-hour ceasefire began on July 26, the body count had reached 856 Palestinians and 40 Israelis dead, as well as several thousand wounded. As I write, the Palestinian toll has reached 1,000. Neither side seemed interested in negotiating a more enduring halt to the fighting or a renewed approach to a peace agreement. Instead, accusations of terrorism and self-righteous proclamations were commonplace. I’m thinking, in the latter case, of Ron Dermer, Israeli ambassador to the US and former US citizen, who said in an interview with the New York Times July 26, “the Israeli Defense Forces should be given a Nobel Peace Prize.” Indictment of Israeli and Hamas leaders for war crimes seems more appropriate.
Left out of the casualty figures, but no less important, are all the people who have been forced from their homes and have become refugees in their own country. This reality, that war’s heaviest impact is on civilian populations, is often obscured by its frequency. People flee as the bombs fall; another refugee camp is set up to house thousands of them; and thousands more line the roads leading to another country. How often have we read such reports?
The United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) says there are around 5 million Palestinians in the Middle East who count as refugees (www.unrwa.org/palestine-refugees), making them the world’s largest refugee population. About a third of them are registered with the agency in 58 (!) camps, located in Gaza, the West Bank, and surrounding countries. The other two-thirds are not in camps. Except for those living in Jordan, Palestinians are stateless; they do not have citizen rights, whether in Israeli-occupied territory or in Syria and Lebanon (http://prrn.mcgill.ca/background/).
With the current Israeli-Palestinian conflict, the figure for Palestinian refugees is rising again. It draws our attention to the desperate worldwide refugee situation. The main United Nations refugee organization—UNHCR, the UN High Commissioner for Refugees—provides statistics and, along with numerous nongovernmental organizations, various forms of relief. Its most recent (2013) report (www.unhcr.org/gr13/index.xml) gives a total worldwide refugee population of around 11.7 million, of whom UNHCR assists about 8.5 million. That figures does not include a staggering 24 million IDPs (internally displaced persons) who, like the refugees, overwhelmingly live in the Middle East and Africa. When all types of forcibly displaced persons are counted, the global figure is over 45 million, the highest total in twenty years.
You can imagine what the costs of helping all these people must be, and how increasingly difficult it must also be to raise adequate funds when the problem keeps growing and when so many other global issues compete for money. At the end of 2013 UNHCR’s budget called for around $5.3 billion; but it only raised about 60 percent of that amount from governments and private sources. (The US, at 36 percent; Japan, at 9 percent; and the European Union at 7 percent are the top three governmental donors. Private donations account for 7 percent of all funding.)
Keeping up with the world refugee crisis is virtually impossible. Just look at what has happened in the Middle East this year. Millions of Syrians and Iraqis have fled to neighboring countries or calmer parts of their own country (such as Kurdish territory in Iraq). Many Iraqi families have become refugees for the second or third time in recent years. Afghani refugees, numbering 2.6 million, are stranded in Pakistan and Iran. Meanwhile, in Africa, very large numbers of people from Somalia, Sudan, Democratic Republic of the Congo, and Eritrea have also been forced to flee. The strain on the budgets of host countries is enormous, and the stresses that providers must face as they try to meet basic needs are huge. Moreover, refugee camps are fertile ground for gangs, recruitment by terrorist groups and political factions, and fights over scarce resources.
And let’s remember that “refugees” does not include migrant workers and their family members. Consider, in the US alone, the roughly 3 million undocumented migrants from Mexico and beyond as well of late as the many thousands of children who have crossed the border alone from Central America. They aren’t exactly receiving a warm welcome from Texans and Arizonans–though I’m pleased to note that the governor of Oregon has declared those children are welcome here. Or take the North Koreans who manage to cross the border with China to escape horrendous repression. They must somehow blend in with the Korean Chinese population; but if they are caught and returned to China, they are treated as migrants and thus denied the rights granted to refugees under international law. We need to remind ourselves that ever since the enormous refugee problem at the end of World War II, refugees who have “a well-founded fear of persecution” have the right to resettlement in another country, and cannot be sent back by the receiving country. Tell that to Beijing.
Interested in helping? Mercy Corps, Catholic Relief Services, Save the Children, Doctors Without Borders, Oxfam, CARE, and the International Committee of the Red Cross are among the many relief organizations that are doing wonderful work. A full list of organizations can be found at www.globalcorps.com/jobs/ngolist.pdf.
Your post 37 has moved me greatly. The numbers of people killed, casualties and displaced, are staggering.
Using Wikipedia, for populations and numbers of people killed in recent wars, I computed deaths as a percentage of the population.
Gaza deaths are already a greater percentage of the population than US deaths in Vietnam war. It’s still less than Vietnamese deaths in Vietnam war, or US deaths in Civil War, or Russian deaths in WW2.
Gaza: pop 1.7 million, 1000 deaths, .05%
Israel: Pop 6 million, 50 deaths, .0008%
US in Vietnam 1970: pop 203 million 55,000 deaths .031%
US pop 1870 39 million 860,000 deaths 2.2%
Vietnam1970: pop 42 million 1 million deaths 2.4%
USSR 1940 192 million 20,000,000 deaths 10%
IThe number of casualties plus refugees is roughly ten times greater than the number sf deaths.. Survivors have to clean up the environment, raise the next generation and we hope educate our kids in the value of peace, not war.
Keep up the good work.
Thanks, Bob. These figures help put the Gaza situation in perspective. The deaths, wounded, and displaced in the Palestinian population add up to a devastating toll of the Gaza population.