Post #287: The End of American Exceptionalism


Whatever you want to call the violent assault in Washington on January 6, 2021—a mob action, a siege, a coup attempt, a riot, domestic terrorism, an insurrection—the fault clearly lies with the president.  Donald Trump called for it, and when it happened—“an act of violent sedition aided and abetted by a lawless, immoral and terrifying president” (New York Times columnist Bret Stephens, January 6)—he praised it.  Joe Biden was correct to use the same language, saying the assault “borders on sedition.” 

What may come of Trump’s last desperate play is hard to say.  Various people, from corporate executives and conservative media to public officials, have called for his removal, whether by impeachment, invocation of the 25th Amendment, resignation, or arrest.  Certainly, Trump deserves immediate removal, before he does any more damage.  He’s a traitor, as I’ve written several times before.  Even some of his most ardent supporters seem to have realized the threat Trump posed to constitutional order.  They made a decision, along with the Democratic leadership, to call out the National Guard without consulting the president.  The decision hasn’t received the attention it deserves.

Here is the statement announcing the decision, issued by Acting Secretary of Defense Chris Miller (Spencer Ackerman on Twitter: “Update: the first statement from Acting Defense Secretary Chris Miller.” / Twitter):

Chairman [of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Mark] Milley and I just spoke separately with the Vice President and with Speaker Pelosi, Leader McConnell, Senator Schumer and Representative Hoyer about the situation at the U.S. Capitol.  We have fully activated the D.C. National Guard to assist federal and local law enforcement as they work to peacefully address the situation. We are prepared to provide additional support as necessary and appropriate as requested by local authorities.  Our people are sworn to defend the constitution and our democratic form of government and they will act accordingly.

Other officials were reportedly involved—just about all the stakeholders except the commander in chief!  One wonders where Trump was when the statement was drafted, and whether or not he was even aware he was being bypassed. No doubt Trump was deliberately excluded knowing he would have opposed bringing in the Guard to crush his “patriotic” supporters.  Also, there was a strong desire, especially in the Pentagon, to avoid using the regular military, which helps explain why it took anywhere from one and a half to two and a half hours before the Guard was deployed.  (Republican Governor Larry Hogan of Maryland said the next day that he immediately authorized his state’s national guard to go to Washington, but was denied permission by Chris Miller—and only got permission hours later from the secretary of the army.) 

In a word, the chain of command dissolved.  It wasn’t exactly the 25th Amendment or removal from office, but the effect was the same: Trump officially became acting president.  He may manage to hang on until January 20, but as General John Kelly, Trump’s former chief of staff, said on CNN, no one will now take illegal orders from Trump (

Democracy in Survival Mode

The immediate consequences of the mob attack are clear: Trump’s last gasp to disrupt the election has failed; Trump himself has lost all credibility as a national leader; and the Forever Trumpers have been forced to a shameful retreat.  But the lasting effects are concerning: the ease with which a right-wing mob penetrated the Capitol and forced Congress members into hiding; the late arrival of security forces, in sharp contrast with the display of overwhelming force when the BLM protests shook Washington last June (remember Trump?: “when the looting starts, the shooting starts”); the vindictive and disruptive effort of 121 House representatives and six Senators to deny Joe Biden’s victory; and the images, circulating worldwide, of the US Capitol under siege from half-crazed Trumpites.

Let’s recall that until January 6, our worst fears had failed to materialize:

  • that Trump’s appointment of Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court would enable him to win an election he had lost at the polls;
  • that Trump would be able to call upon various national guard units or the military to protect him from being ousted;
  • that the departments of justice and homeland security would mobilize to support him;
  • that Trump would declare martial law to stay in power;
  • that Trump could count on various states’ electors to overturn the popular vote;
  • that Trump’s legal teams would not only swamp state courts with litigation but win in them;
  • that the US Postal Service would be able to prevent millions of people from receiving absentee or mail-in ballots;
  • that Trump would simply refuse to leave the White House;

Back then, we thought the worst had passed, thanks to the “eternal vigilance” Thomas Jefferson spoke of—the integrity of those who manage and operate the electoral machinery, the grassroots organizations that stood watch, and the tens of millions of people who cast their ballots despite intimidation and amidst constant official lying. In fact, democracy won on November 3, but not by much.  All those Republicans who kept faith with Trump as he denied Biden’s victory; all those Republican members of Congress and Trump’s cabinet who dared not criticize him before January 6, when they suddenly found their spine; and all those people who not only rallied to Trump’s appeals but threatened public officials who dared contradict him—they were and are still out there. Eternal vigilance may not be enough next time.

In short, the shared myth of American exceptionalism died on January 6, 2021.  Americans who thought “it can’t happen here” have now seen it happen—not just a president’s support of an insurrectionary riot, but his consistent abetment of violence and disruption for his personal benefit.  For four years a Republican majority has tolerated this man’s undermining of democracy and embrace of dictators whose absolute power he envies.  He ranted and raved, humiliated and cowed, lied endlessly, reveling in his immunity and media attention.  Only now are there signs of willingness to remove so dangerous a man, and only now is he being barred from some social media—for a while.  It might be too little, too late to repair Trump’s “American carnage.”

Democrats will shortly have complete political control and a decent interval in which to get something done. The Biden team will have to deliver on the pandemic, the economy, global warming, and much else against formidable odds that are made worse by the far right’s anticipated sabotage.  Expect it to be far worse than anything Bill Clinton or Barack Obama experienced.  Progressives face a serious challenge: push their agenda too hard and give fodder to the Trumpites; refrain from pushing hard and wind up with weak reforms or nothing at all.  Biden will have to be pressed to abandon dreams of bipartisan cooperation when the stakes are high.  On many issues, starting with climate change and environmental protection, he must be prepared to use his Congressional majorities like a hammer as well as act by executive authority, just like all his predecessors.  So be it; the public interest demands it, and Republicans will either support it or be pushed aside.  One never knows when such an opportune moment will come again.

Categories: Tags: , , , , ,


  1. Quoting Gurtov: “Progressives face a serious challenge: push their agenda too hard and give fodder to the Trumpites; refrain from pushing hard and wind up with weak reforms or nothing at all. ”
    An article in yesterday’s Wall St. Journal illustrates the concern. Apparently Speaker Pelosi is considering whether or not to allow Rep. Katie Porter, a member of the very important House Financial Services Committee, to remain on the committee. Porter, a former professor of banking and consumer protection law and a protege of Elizabeth Warren, has been the most effective member of the committee and the bane of predatory lenders. Moving her off the committee would be a massive, self-imposed injury for progressives. Why is the Speaker hesitating to re-appoint Katie Porter when she should be doing cartwheels for the opportunity to elicit her service?
    A little grassroots support for Porter (contact your member of Congress and/or Senator’s office) might be a timely and tangible way to meet the challenge Mel refers to.

    1. Katie Porter is one of my favorite legislators. She does her homework, is a formidable presence on the committee, and–as Larry says–has been a very effective committee member on behalf of consumer protection. I don’t get this reported move by Pelosi, unless it’s personal. Let’s follow Larry’s suggestion in support of Porter.

  2. Yes. Sad day but possibly a wake up call. Unless we can address social media and declining incomes for the 90 percent there will be more.

    Liberals are too slow to invoke the golden rule and other traditional touchstones. Corps Have a strangle hold on body politic to work against their self interests.

    Censure under the 14 amendment would do the job and force a vote

    Sent from my iPhone


  3. Here’s my response today to Prof Gurtov’s deeply felt posting yesterday to the Thirsters listserver (below)…
    In looking online for a detailed CV of Prof. Gurtov, while there’s a surfeit of references to his sterling academic and intellectual attainments, I somehow couldn’t find anything about him having served as an infantry officer in any of the overseas wars that Gurtov thinks are a sina qua non of American Exceptionalism and of meeting our “international obligations”. So I imagine that he thinks that the proper cannon fodder for these bloodly adventures is best comprised of White Nationalist deplorable lowlifes from flyover country. Two birds with one stone!
    Alan Potkin, Ph. D.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s